Rob Berger

12 Best Quicken Alternatives in 2022 (#1 is Free)

May 12, 2022 by Rob Berger

Quicken was once the go-to budgeting tool. I used it when it was first released in the 1980s. Today, it’s been eclipsed by apps that enable you to manage every aspect of your finances, often for free. Here are the best Quicken alternatives to consider in 2022.

Quicken alternatives — Options to replace Quicken

Editor’s Top Picks

Of all the options out there to replace Quicken (and Mint for that matter), three stand out among the rest:

Personal Capital–It’s both free and comes with the a robust set of features unmatched by other alternatives. It easily handles budgeting, net worth, cash flow, retirement investments and taxable investments. It also comes with excellent tools, including a retirement calculator, investment fee analyzer and investment portfolio analyzer. Personal Capital can now even track Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin and thousands of other tokens. It’s the tool I use every day.
Tiller–If you are a diehard spreadsheet fanatic, Tiller is the answer. It integrates with Google Sheets and can connect your bank accounts and credit cards. It also offers daily email updates to track your spending. You can try it free for 30 days, then it’s $79 a year.
YNAB (You Need a Budget): For those who want to focus exclusively on budgeting (no investments), then YNAB is an ideal choice. It does budgeting as well as any app available today, and its community is second to none.

Quicken Alternatives

Top Quicken Alternatives

1. Personal Capital–Editor’s Choice

Personal Capital is the clear winner when it comes to finding a substitute for Quicken. It’s free and it offers tools to manage every aspect of your finances. With Personal Capital, you can link just about every financial account you have–checking, savings, credit cards, retirement accounts, investments accounts, HSAs, and even your home (via Zillow).

Once linked, Personal Capital’s financial dashboard offers valuable insights into your finances. As an example, the tool enables you to–

Track your spending by category
Estimate when you can retire
Calculate the cost of your investments
Display the asset allocation of your portfolio
Generate a net worth statement
Get alerts when bills are due
Evaluate your investment portfolio
Save for emergencies
New: Track Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin and thousands of other tokens without giving access to your crypto wallet.

I’ve used Personal Capital for years. It’s the only option that in my opinion can handle every aspect of my finances, from budgeting to investing to retirement planning.

Try Personal Capital

I’ve written a detailed review and guide of Personal Capital that you can check out.

2. Tiller Money–Best Spreadsheet Budget

I don’t know how they do it, but Tiller Money has figured out how to turn a Google Sheet into a dynamic budgeting tool. You link your bank accounts and credit cards to Tiller’s Google Sheet tool, and it automatically downloads all of your transactions. From there you can create budgets, categorize spending and generate reports.

I’ve been using Tiller for about one year for both my personal budget and my small business budget. Tiller is ideal for those who love working with spreadsheets. I will caution you that setting up Tiller can be a bit daunting. The good news is that they have videos to walk you through each step. If I can do it, you can do it.

One thing to keep in mind is that you must manually categorize each transaction. For some, this is a show-stopper. They want the convenience of tools like Personal Capital that automate this process. For others, they would prefer to categorize transactions themselves. It forces them to look at each entry, understand how they spent money, and then properly categorize the expense. Tiller does offer an auto-category tool that you can use to automatically categorize transactions based on the description.

There is no right or wrong here. It comes down to preference. You get a 30-day free trial. After that Tiller costs $79 a year.

3. You Need a Budget (YNAB)–Best for Budgeting

YNAB is ideal for those looking just for a budgeting tool. In my view, there is no better app when it comes to creating a budget. YNAB’s interface is similar to a spreadsheet. The tool makes it easy to budget by category based on the money you actually have in the bank.

One of YNAB’s core principles is to give every dollar a job. You do that by deciding how you’ll spend every dollar that enters your checking account. As with other tools, you can connect your bank accounts and credit cards to YNAB. This allows for real-time updates so that you can track your spending throughout the month.

YNAB doesn’t have the rich feature set offered by Personal Capital. That’s particularly clear when it comes to investing. For those who don’t want to track investments, however, YNAB is a good option.

It’s not free, however. You can try it free for 34 days. After that it costs $11.99 a month or $84 a year for the annual plan. The cost is the biggest downside to YNAB.

4. PocketSmith–Best for Calendar Budgeting

PocketSmith started out as a calendar to plan upcoming income and expenses. Today, it’s a full-fledged budgeting app. You can synch your accounts with PocketSmith. Once synced, you can track your budget and you’re net worth. You can also see your income and spending in a handy calendar view.

One stand-out feature is PocketSmith’s auto-budget tool. It can create a budget for you based on past spending. It also has a cash flow feature that maps income and spending by date range.

While there is a free version of PocketSmith, it requires manual data entry. To get automatic bank fees, you’ll need to pay at least $9.95 a month, or $7.50 a month when paid annually.

5. CountAbout–Imports from Quicken or Mint

If you have a lot of data in Quicken (or Mint), CountAbout may be the budgeting tool for you. It has a feature enabling you to import data from Quicken or Mint.

CountAbout enables you to download transactions from your bank and customize both income and expense categories. You can even attach receipt images to expense transactions. You can set up recurring transactions and generate financial reports.

For the features you get, the cost is very reasonable. The basic plan costs just $9.99 a year (not a month). If you want automatic downloading of bank transactions, the cost is $39.99 a year.

6. Moneydance–Traditional Budgeting Software

With so many apps going online, Moneydance takes a different approach. You download Moneydance software rather than use it online. Once downloaded, the software works much like you would expect.

You can download banking transactions into the software and initiate bill pay. The software automatically categorizes expenses based on how you categorize them. In other words, it learns from your use of the program.

It offers a dashboard (shown above) that summarizes your finances all in one place. It can also generate reports and graphs to give you a visual perspective of your money. It comes with a mobile app, can track your finances, and can alert you when bills are due.

It costs $49.99 and is available for both Mac and Windows.

7. EveryDollar (now Ramsey+)–Best for Dave Ramsey Fans

For those Dave Ramsey founds out there, EveryDollar may be a good substitute for Intuit’s Quicken. Now the first thing to point out is that EveryDollar ain’t cheap. After a 14-day trial, you’ll pay $129.99 a year. If you want to try it for just 3 months, it will cost $59.99. For this reason, it’s not high on my list. Still, I know that some folks are passionate about Financial Peace University.

You can sync your bank accounts with the tool, set up budgets, and track spending. The budgeting app works on both computers, smartphones and tablets. It also comes with Dave’s educational materials, enabling you to take online course and join virtual groups.

8. Banktivity–Designed for Macs Only

Banktivity is the budgeting app specifically designed for Macs. It offers features that enable you to organize and track all of your finances. You can group accounts and reports, and organize the dashboard in a way that works best for you.

Banktivity enables you to follow an envelope budget. This can be ideal for those living paycheck-to-paycheck.

You can import transactions from your bank and sync data across all of your Mac devices. Banktivity also tracks investments and offers account-level reporting. You can try Banktivity for free for 30 days. After that they offer three plans ranging in price from $4.16 to $8.33 a month (billed annually).

9. GnuCash–Best for Small Businesses

For those who tracked business income and expenses with Quicken and a reluctant to move up to Quickbooks, GnuCash may be the answer. It uses double-entry accounting, ideal for businesses and accounting nerds, like me. It tracks investments, schedules transactions, and generates reports and graphs.

10. Mint–Best Mobile App

I used Mint when it first came out more than a decade ago. Today, many are looking for Mint alternatives, including several of the apps listed here. Still, Mint is a worth consideration if you are replacing Intuit’s Quicken. It’s free, for starters. It’s easy to link your accounts and track your spending. It includes a budget planner and credit score tracker. Of course, there are great Mint alternatives as well.

11. GoodBudget–Best for Envelope Budgeting

I’m old enough to remember the envelope method of budgeting. My mom used it. When the money in the grocery envelope ran out, we stopped going to the grocery story until payday (seriously). Today, the envelope budget is still a smart way to manage money for those living paycheck-to-paycheck. If you want a digital version of the time-tested budgeting system, give GoodBudget a try.

Goodudget is an app based on the envelope system. You can sync and share your budget, and set goals to save for big purchases. It also has tools that let you track and payoff your debt.

12. Monarch Money–Best for Couples

Monarch Money shares many of the features in the apps listed above. You can connect all your accounts, including investment and loan accounts. Once connected, Monarch syncs your accounts to generate your net worth. The app enables you to see all your transactions in one place, set financial goals, and customize your financial dashboard.

Monarch is ideal for couples because of its collaboration features. Invite someone to your Monarch account with a separate login. They can view your data and connect their own accounts. This feature is particularly useful for couples that keep separate accounts, but want to understand their combined financial picture.

Try Monarch Money for free for 7 days, then as little as $7.50 a month.

Quicken Alternatives FAQs

What is the best free alternative to Quicken?

Personal Capital is the best free Quicken replacement. It comes with nearly every feature Quicken offers, and money additional tools. It’s particularly well suited for those who want to manage all of their money in one place, including investments.

Is Quicken available without a subscription?

Sadly, no. Like so many other software packages and apps, Quicken is now only available as a subscription. As a result, you must pay for Quicken every year.

What is the best option to migrate Quicken data to new app?

If you want to migrate Quicken data to a new budgeting app, CountAbout is a solid option. It has features enabling users to migrate data from Quicken or Mint.

What is the best Quicken replacement for calendar budgeting?

PocketSmith is a good choice as it offers a calendar view of your budget.

Which Quicken alternatives allow you to schedule bill payments?

With both Tiller Money and YNAB, you can plan future bill payments. Tiller offers a Bill Payment Tracker template and YNAB enables you to allocate funds to bills you plan to pay in the future.

Whatever tool you choose, the key is to pick one that works for you. For me, that’s Personal Capital. One or more of the above Quicken alternatives, however, should suit the needs of most looking to better manage their money.

Series I Savings Bond Rates to Rise Near 10% (Updated April 2022)

April 13, 2022 by Rob Berger

Series I Savings Bonds rates are set to rise to historic levels, again. The Labor Department released Consumer Price Index (CPI-U) data this week that showed prices rising by 8.5% for the 12 months ending Marcy 2022 and 4.81% over the past six months. As a result, the Inflation Rate on I Bonds is expected to rise to a whopping 9.62% in May 2022 (the rate is currently 7.12% annualized).That represents the highest Inflation Rate on I Bonds since they were first introduced in 1998.

How I Bond Rates Are Set

Two factors determine the interest rate on an I bond: A Fixed Rate and an Inflation Rate. Combining these two rates gives us what is known as the Composite Rate.

Fixed Rate

The Fixed Rate is set based on the date of purchase. Today the Fixed Rate is 0%. The Fixed Rate was above 3% in the late 1990s and early 2000s. It’s been at 0% for much of the past decade.

The Treasury announces the Fixed Rate on I bonds every six months, on the first business day of May and November. The Fixed Rate is an annual rate that compounds every six months. The big question is whether the Treasury will increase the fixed rate in May.

Many predict that the fixed rate will remain at 0%. While I agree with this assessment, it’s a closer call. The real yield on 10-year TIPS (Treasury Inflation Protected Securities) has jumped to from -1.04 to -0.12 in one month.

I suspect the fixed rate won’t rise until real yields on TIPS get about 25 basis points above 0%. This is important for I bond buying strategies (see below). It’s important to understand that the Fixed Rate at the time of purchase applies for the duration of the bond (30 years).

Get access to multiple FDIC-insured savings and money market accounts with just one account at SaveBetter.

Try SaveBetter

Rates: Up to 1.06% APY
Monthly Fee: $0
Minimum Deposit: $1
FDIC insured: Yes

Inflation Rate

Unlike the Fixed Rate, the Inflation Rate changes every six months over the life of an I bond. The rate is set based on changes in the non-seasonally adjusted Consumer Price Index for all Urban Consumers (CPI-U) for all items, including food and energy. As with the Fixed Rate, the Inflation Rate is set on the first business day in May and November.

Keep in mind that the date new rates apply to a specific I bond depends on the month in which you bought it. Here’s a table of when new rates will take effect:

Issue month of your bond	New rates take effect
January	January 1 and July 1
February	February 1 and August 1
March	March 1 and September 1
April	April 1 and October 1
May	May 1 and November 1
June	June 1 and December 1
July	July 1 and January 1
August	August 1 and February 1
September	September 1 and March 1
October	October 1 and April 1
November	November 1 and May 1
December	December 1 and June 1

Composite Rate

The Composite Rate is the annualized rate based on adding the Fixed Rate to the Inflation Rate. Through April 2022, Composite Rate is 7.12%. Beginning in May 2022 for the following six months, the Composite Rate will jump to 9.62% thanks to rising inflation.

How I Bonds Work

There are several features of I bonds to keep in mind before investing.

First, you can only buy I bonds directly from the Treasury. They are not bought and sold on the secondary market. This means, among other things, that you won’t find I bonds in an ETF or mutual fund portfolio.

Second, the government imposes a limit on the amount of money that you can invest in I bonds each year. You can invest $10,000 a year per social security number through Treasury Direct. You can also purchase up to $5,000 through your federal tax refund.

Third, you must keep your investment in an I bond for at least one year. You can’t sell the bond back to the government during this time. If you sell before holding the bond for five years, you also lose three months of interest.

Fourth, if you own a business, the business entity can also invest in I bonds. This is something I just learned. My business will be buying $10,000 in I bonds this month.

Finally, you can defer paying income tax on interest until you sell the bond. In addition, you’ll owe no state income tax.

When Should You Buy I Bonds

When you should buy I bonds turns on whether you plan to be a long-term or short-term investor.

Long-Term Investor

For long-term investors, I would buy at the end of April, if you haven’t already purchased I bonds this year. As the chart above shows, you’ll earn the current Inflation Rate from April 2022 through September 2022. Beginning in October 2022, you’ll then earn the new rate of 9.62% for six months.

The key point is that for long-term investors, it’s likely that the Inflation Rate will fall below its current level at some point. As a result, it makes sense to take advantage of the current rate. And while the Fixed Rate will reset in May, it’s unlikely to rise about 0% in my opinion. Of course, there’s no guarantee, but it seems like a reasonable bet in my view.

Short-Term Investor

For investors who plan to sell after one year, I’d follow the same strategy. At the end of last year my recommendation was to wait:

I’d wait until November. I think it’s likely that the Inflation Rate in May 2022 will be higher than the current 3.56%. By waiting until November, investors will receive the 7.12% for six months, followed by the new rate set in May of next year. While it’s certainly possible that the Inflation Rate next year could fall below the current 3.56%, I view that as unlikely given the current trends in the CPI.

Today I’m less certain that the next inflation adjustment will be as attractive. There are already some signs of core inflation moderating. Just keep in mind that accurately predicting inflation and interest rates is impossible. For me today, a “bird in the hand” rules the day.

Keep in mind that if you sell after one year, you’ll lose 3 months of interest. Even so, the return will far exceed what savers can earn on a deposit account.

I Bonds vs CDs

Given the current and upcoming yields on I bonds, they are significantly better than even the best CD rates. That’s true even if one plans to sell the I bond after one year and incur the 3-month interest penalty. The key difference is that with I bonds, you cannot liquidate for the first year. With a CD, you can always withdraw your money, subject to an interest penalty.

I use Personal Capital to track all of my investments. The free tool shows me my asset allocation, total costs, and even retirement projections. Check out my Personal Capital Review and User’s Guide to learn how it can help you, too.

I Bond Resources

Treasury Direct: https://www.treasurydirect.gov/indiv/research/indepth/ibonds/res_ibonds.htm
TIPS Watch: https://tipswatch.com/tracking-inflation-and-i-bonds/
Deposit Accounts: https://www.depositaccounts.com/blog/inflation-treasury-series-i-savings-bonds/

A List of Low Cost Financial Advisors (Say NO to 1% Advisors)

March 29, 2022 by Rob Berger

Investment advisors charging one percent of the investments they manage for you is the industry norm. Many charge more than that.

Not sure how fees may affect your wealth over time, then check out this report.

In an effort keep more of your money in your pocket, I’ve created this list of low cost financial advisors. It includes both flat-fee advisors as well as those who charge 50 basis points (1/2%) or less.

Please understand that I am not recommending these advisors. You’ll need to do your own due diligence to determine whether they are a good fit for your financial needs and goals.

Mark Zoril

Planvision
Fees: $239 the first year, then $8/month (https://planvisionmn.com/faq/)
Services: Financial planning, investment management

Rick Ferri

Website
Fee: $450/hour (https://rickferri.com/faqs/#collapse-1-10941)
Services: Hourly advice for DIY investors

Andy Panko

Tenon Financial (not accepting new clients)
Fee: $9,600/year (couple); $8,400/year (individual)
Services: Financial planning, tax, investment management

Asset Builder

Website
Fee: 0.35% (on average)
Services: Investment management using DFA funds

Vanguard Advisor Services

Website
Fee: 0.30% ($50,000 minumum)
Services: Financial planning, investment management

Andrew Dressel, CFP®, APMA®, CRPC®

Abundo Wealth
Fee: $375-$450 start-up fee, then $89-$139/month
Services: Financial planning

Michael T. Powers, CPA, PFS, CFP®

Manuka Financial
Fee: $950 initial fee + an ongoing flat fee of $1,250 – $6,250 per quarter
Services: Retirement planning, investment management, tax preparation

Jon Luskin, CFP

Website
Fee: For a one-time financial review, you pay a one-time fee: $1,725. Additional in-depth work (many clients don’t need this) and returning clients are billed at $350 an hour.
Services: Hourly advice for DIY investors

Here’s a list of flat-fee planners put together by Cody Garrett, CFP.

Here’s a list of flat-fee and advisors put together by Sara Grillo.

If you know of other advisors who should make this list, please let me know.

4 Best Robo-Advisors in 2022 (Out of 23 Evaluated)

March 22, 2022 by Rob Berger

Robo-Advisors promise to make investing easy at a very low cost. Investors have taken notice. According to one estimate, automated investing platforms will manage nearly $1.5 trillion by 2023. With dozens of options, however, picking the best robo-advisor can be overwhelming.

To help, I examined about two dozen robos and narrowed them down to what I think are the top four choices. Note that I have used all four robo advisors that made this list. I’m continue to test other services and may update this list in the future.

Best Robo-Advisors

Betterment–Best Overall Robo-Advisor

I’ve helped family members and friends set up their first investment account. After explaining the pros and cons of traditional brokers and robo-advisors, they have all chosen Betterment. There are several reasons why Betterment is such a popular choice.

Ease of Use: With Betterment, you select your account type, answer a few questions about your goals, and fund your account (check or bank transfer). From there, Betterment does the rest. It invests your money in a several low cost ETFs that give you a diversified portfolio of stocks and bonds.

In addition to the core portfolios above, it also offers several socially responsible investing portfolios.

Betterment Socially Responsibly Portfolios

Account Types: Betterment offers a wide range of account types, including:

Roth and Traditional IRA
SEP IRA (single participant only)
Inherited IRA
Individual taxable accounts
Joint taxable accounts with rights of survivorship
Trust accounts

Beyond investment accounts, it also offers deposit accounts:

Cash Reserve (a high-yield cash account)
Checking account provided by nbkc bank, Member FDIC.

Features: Apart from its easy of use, Betterment’s long list of features earn it the top spot as the best robo-advisor:

Rebalancing: Automatically rebalances your investment accounts.
Automated Investing: Set up recurring deposits to your account and automatically reinvest dividends and interest.
Tax Tools: Betterment offers several features to reduce your taxes, including tax loss harvesting, tax efficient rebalancing, and asset location.
Planning: Track any number of financial goals, including retirement or saving for a child’s education.
Financial Dashboard: See all of your finances in one place, including assets held at other financial institutions.
Advisor Help: Unlike most robo-advisors, Betterment has Certified Financial Planners available to help you.

Low Fees: Betterment offers three fee levels:

No Fee: You can open a no-fee checking account (comes with a free Visa debit card) or a Cash Reserve account.
0.25%: Digital investing with no minimum balance (comes to about $2.50 a year for every $1,000 invested).
0.40%: Premium investing that includes unlimited calls and emails with Betterment’s team of CFPs (requires a $100,000 minimum balance).

Finally, Betterment is ideal for every stage of an investor’s journey. It’s easy to open up your first account, with no minimum requirements. And betterment offers a wealth of tools for those entering retirement who need to start withdrawing money to live on.

Try Betterment

M1 Finance–Best No-Fee Robo with Ultimate Flexibility

For those that want the automation of a robo-advisor, no fees, and complete control of your investment strategy, M1 Finance is without question the top choice. It blends the benefits of traditional brokers with the automation of robo-advisors.

M1 enables investors to create what they call Pies. Each pie can hold individual stocks, ETFs or both. For each investment you add to a Pie, you also indicate how big each slice is. For example, you could create a Pie with the following investments:

VTI (50%): Vanguard’s Total U.S. Stock Market ETF
VXUS (30%): Vanguard’s Total International Stock Market ETF
BND (20%): Vanguards Total U.S. Bond ETF

The above is what is called the three fund portfolio.

Where M1 really stands out is how easy it makes investing in the Pies of your choice. Using the three fund portfolio above as an example, M1 will automatically allocate your investments based on the percentages you set.

As markets cause your balances in each ETF to vary from your plan, M1 takes any new contributions and investments as necessary to bring your investment Pie back in line with your plan. And if your contributions aren’t sufficient, you can rebalance a pie with the click of a button.

In addition to investing, M1 offers a high-yield checking account and an excellent cash back credit card.

Try M1 Finance

Blooom

Blooom is unique among robo-advisors. It was designed to work with 401(k) plans and other workplace retirement accounts. In fact, it’s the only one on the list that can help investors manage a 401(k). It’s also one of the least expensive robo-advisors (along with M1 Finance).

With Blooom the first step is to connect your accounts. You can connect workplace retirement accounts and IRA accounts. Blooom will analyze your investments and make suggestions based on your goals. The analysis is free, and for those who don’t need help buying and selling within their accounts, this could be all you need.

For those who want more help, Blooom offers several paid plans. With the Personalized Plan, you’ll get personalized fund recommendations based on your specific accounts, financial goals and risk tolerance. The cost is just $120 per year.

With the Advisor Access Plan, you can have Blooom place trades on your behalf. You also get access to financial advisor via chat or email. Keep in mind, however, that you would be responsible for placing your own trades. In this way, it’s not as hands-off as Betterment or Wealthfront. The cost of this plan is $165 per year.

Finally, you can schedule a one-on-one call with a financial advisor for $295 per year.

Try Blooom

Wealthfront

Finally, Wealthfront rounds out my list of the best robo-advisors. Similar to Betterment, it provides a wealth of investing automation for a fee of just 25 basis points. Its list of features is similar to Betterment, with some notable differences.

Before getting those features and differences, however, it’s important to point out that Wealthfront announced in January 2022 that it had agreed to be acquired by UBS. How this will affect Wealthfront is unclear.

Wealthfront offers a Classic, Socially Responsible and Direct Indexing approach to investing. With a Classic portfolio, you get diversification across U.S. stocks, international stocks, and bonds. You can also chose among socially responsible ETFs.

Unlike Betterment, Wealthfront also offers what is called direct indexing for accounts with at least $100,000. With direct indexing, Wealthfront invests in 100 to 600 stocks, rather than a total U.S. stock ETF such as VTI. The idea is to get the returns of an index, but with tax loss harvesting and asset location flexibility.

On the negative side, Wealthfront does not offer the help of a CFP, as Betterment does.

Try Wealthfront

Why Vanguard Digital Advisor Didn’t Make the Cut

At first glance, Vanguard Digital Advisor checks all the boxes. It offers automated investing using Vanguard ETFs. Generally Vanguard uses four ETFs to implement its investment strategy on your behalf:

VTI: Total U.S. Stock Market
VXUS: Total International Stock Market
BND: Total U.S. Bond Market
BNDX: Total International Bond Market

Vanguard automatically rebalances the portfolio periodically to keep the portfolio in line with your investment goals. In addition to investing, Digital Advisor can also help you achieve other goals, such as getting out of debt.

And if all that weren’t enough, the cost is about 0.15%, which includes the cost of the underlying ETFs.

So why doesn’t it make the cut?

Well, it wasn’t until I used the service that I experienced its many shortcomings.

First, there have been a number of technology issues. Do you see the pretty graph in the image above showing the investor’s progress? Here’s what mine looks like:

Vanguard tells me they are working on it.

For a week I couldn’t even enroll in the service. I kept getting this message:

Problems enrolling in Vanguard Digital Advisor

These issues may be temporary, but it gets worse.

Unlike other robo-advisors, you are limited to just five initial asset allocations. Once selected, you are limited in the changes you can make to the asset allocation. And, similar to a target date retirement fund, Vanguard will change your asset allocation as you near your retirement goal.

What’s more, you can’t tell Vanguard to leave your asset allocation alone. It changes whether you like it or not. The result is that Digital Advisor is not well suited for taxable accounts.

And even if you want to use the service in an IRA, you’d be better off with a Vanguard Target Date Fund. These funds use the same funds and cost just 8 basis points. Why pay 15 basis points for effectively the same thing. (A Vanguard rep told me that one can customize the glidepath with Digital Advisor a bit more than with a TDR fund, but the differences seem minimal at best).

In short, Vanguard’s Digital Advisor fails to make the grade.

The True Cost of “Free” Robo Advisors

There are two “free” robo-advisors that did not make my list of the top four–SoFi and Schwab Intelligent Portfolios. In both cases it’s because they have “hidden” fees. Let me explain.

SoFi

SoFi is best known for its student loan business. Several years ago it began to broaden its financial services offerings, including SoFi Automated Investing. While it doesn’t charge a management fee, they get their money another way. Let me explain.

Here’s the portfolio that SoFi suggests for me (I assumed a $1 million contribution, but the amount isn’t important):

When you click in the View details link, here are the specific funds SoFi uses:

Notice that the selected funds include two SoFi ETFs. That’s how SoFi makes its money. And those funds are expensive and not what you might think they are.

For example, the SoFI Select 500 ETF is NOT an S&P 500 index fund. It doesn’t track that index, instead tracking something called the Solactive SoFi US 500 Growth Index. And it costs 19 basis points each year. While not outrageous, solid S&P 500 index funds typically cost less than 5 basis points.

Does this make SoFi a “bad” robo-advisor. I wouldn’t go that far. But its pricing isn’t as transparent as it should be in my opinion, and I have no interest in tracking a SoFi index with my investments. For these reasons, it didn’t make the list of the best robos.

Schwab Intelligent Portfolios

Schwab entered the robo-advisor market with its Intelligent Portfolios. Like SoFi, there are no management fees charged by Schwab. Investors just pay the fees of the underlying ETFs. Unlike SoFi, Schwab doesn’t force you to invest in ETFs that track a proprietary index.

So what’s the problem?

Schwab forces you to keep at least 6% of your portfolio in cash. And that’s how Schwab makes its money. The amount of cash you must keep goes up as your portfolio becomes more conservative.

For example, a Moderate Growth portfolio requires 9% in cash:

I would much prefer for Schwab just to charge a management fee rather than requiring a significant cash position. At least then the costs would be transparent.

Methodology

My first step in creating this list was to identify a complete list of automated investing platforms. In addition to those listed above, I considered the following:

Etrade Core Portfolios: https://us.etrade.com/what-we-offer/our-accounts/core-portfolios
Axos Managed Portfolios: https://www.axos.com/invest
Acorns
Fidelity Go: https://www.fidelity.com/managed-accounts/fidelity-go/overview
Morgan Stanley Access Investing: https://www.morganstanley.com/what-we-do/wealth-management/access-investing/my-goals
Merrill Edge Guided Investing: ttps://www.merrilledge.com/guided-investing
Wells Fargo Intuitive Investor: https://www.wellsfargoadvisors.com/services/intuitive-investor/how-it-works.htm
Zacks Advantage: https://www.zacksadvantage.com/
UBS Advice Advantage: https://adviceadvantage.ubs.com/
FutureAdvisor (Blackrock): https://www.blackrock.com/futureadvisor
Stash: https://www.stash.com/smart-portfolio-investing
Ally Invest Robo Portfolios
SigFig
Ellevest
Interactive Advisors

I then considered the following factors:

Cost
Ease of Use
Account Types
Underlying ETFs used in portfolios
Additional features (particularly as it relates to planning and retirement)

Note that just because a robo-advisor didn’t make the list of the best doesn’t mean the service isn’t worth considering. For example, Acorns is a solid option for those looking for a round-up app.

How to Choose the Best Robo-Advisor for Your Needs

Robo-Advisor	Best for
Betterment	Best overall robo-advisor
M1 Finance	Best free robo-advisor
Blooom	Best for 401(k) and 403(b) accounts
Vanguard Digital Advisors	Best for Vanguard fans
Wealthfront	Best for large taxable accounts

Final Thoughts

Robo-advisors can simplify the process of investing for your future. Not all automated investing services are the same, however. It’s important to understand how a service works, its fees, and its portfolio construction before investing.

7 Best Mint Alternatives in 2022 (Free & Paid)

February 9, 2022 by Rob Berger

Mint was one of the first free online budgeting apps when it launched in 2007. Intuit purchased Mint in 2009, and today many users are looking to replace Mint with a different personal finance app. Here are the 7 best Mint alternatives worth considering.

In this Article

Top Mint.com Alternative Picks

Of all the options out there to replace Mint, three stand out among the rest:

Personal Capital–I’ve used Personal Capital for years. It offers the most robust budgeting, cash flow, investment tracking, and financial tools of any app out there. And it’s free.
Tiller–For those focused on budgeting (but not investing), Tiller is my favorite budgeting app. It connects your financial accounts (banks, credit cards, and even investments) with Google Sheets. It offers a wealth of tools to analyze everything from your monthly budget to even business expenses. You can try it free for 30 days, then it’s $79 a year.
Monarch Money–This is an excellent alternative if you manage money as a couple and don’t like spreadsheets. It offers a mobile app and the ability to connect all of your accounts in one place.
YNAB–This is the Mint replacement of choice if you want a powerful tool that does just one thing, and does it well–budgeting. I’ve known the founder for about a decade and used the tool for years.

Best Alternatives to Mint Budget Tracker

1. Personal Capital–Best Overall Alternative to Mint.com

Personal Capital can easily replace Mint. Like Mint it’s free, and it offers far more tools to keep track of your finances and analyze your investments. You can link just about any financial account to Personal Capital’s app. Once linked, the dashboard gives you a complete snapshot of your money.

Beyond a high level view, Personal Capital offers a number of useful features:

Track spending by category or account
Plan your retirement with the Retirement Planner
Understand how investment fees erode your wealth
Monitor your portfolio’s asset allocation
Track your net worth
Get alerts when bills are due
Save for emergencies
New: Track Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin and thousands of other tokens without giving access to your crypto wallet

I’ve written a detailed review and guide of Personal Capital that you can check out.

Try Personal Capital

2. Tiller Money–Best for those who love spreadsheets

For those focused primarily on budgeting, Tiller Money is the best Mint alternative on our list. Along with Personal Capital, I use Tiller every single day. There is, however, a bit of a learning curve. But once you understand how it works, it’s a breeze to use.

In short, Tiller enables you to connect your bank accounts, credit cards and even investment accounts to a Google Sheet (or Excel). It then gives you templates and tools to do everything from create a budget to track your spending to save for retirement.

The more I use Tiller the more I appreciate the simplicity and ease of use. If you like spreadsheets, you’ll like Tiller. To get an idea of how it works, check out this video I created.

Some of Tiller’s features include:

Track all your accounts in one place
Make a budget, track spending
Track your net worth with flexible, automated dashboards
Create your own category rules so every expense is automatically categorized accurately
Use flexible templates for budgeting and retirement planning
Works with 2FA (2-Factor Authentication)

You get a 30-day free trial. After that Tiller costs $79 a year.

3. CountAbout–Best for converting data from Mint

If you have a lot of data in Mint, CountAbout may be the budgeting tool for you. It has a feature enabling you to import data from Mint. In fact, you can import your entire Mint history into CountAbout.

Unlike Mint, CountAbout doesn’t pummel you with advertisements. It does enable you to download transactions from your bank and customize both income and expense categories. You can save receipt images and attach them to the appropriate expense if record keeping is important.

Key features of CountAbout include:

Import from Quicken or Mint.com
Automate Transaction Downloads
Fully customizable income and spending categories and tags
Invoicing for small businesses
Attachment capability for receipts and images
Recurring transactions
Graphical and text-based “widgets” provide quick view of financial activity
Easy to use on web and iOS/Android apps

For the features you get, the cost is very reasonable. The basic plan costs just $9.99 a year (not a month). If you want automatic downloading of bank transactions, the cost is $39.99 a year.

4. Simplifi–Best budgeting app for smartphones

Simplifi is Quicken’s version of a mobile budgeting app. It’s not a mobile app for Quicken. It’s a new app built from the ground up. It uses automation to help you better manage your money.

For example, Simplifi can create a spending plan for you by analyzing your income and expenses. You can identify recurring expenses and subscriptions, which Simplifi then incorporates into the plan. It also includes a calendar view showing you upcoming expenses.

Key features of Simplifi include:

See your banking, credit card, loans and investments all in one place
Have your transactions automatically categorized
Find and track recurring bills and subscriptions so you can cancel what you no longer use
View upcoming bills, income, transfers, and see how they affect your balances
Set up custom watchlists and limits by category, payee, or tags to help stay on track
Set up savings goals for every milestone you are trying to reach
Track refunds on returned items

You can try Simplifi free for 30-days, then the cost is as low as $2.99 a month.

5. You Need a Budget (YNAB)–Best for budgeting

YNAB is ideal for those looking just for a budgeting tool. YNAB’s interface is similar to a spreadsheet. The tool makes it easy to budget by category based on the money you actually have in the bank. It’s not useful as an investment tracking app, however.

YNAB’s key features include:

Access to real-time information, from any device, anytime
Track goals
Excellent charts and graphs

It’s not free, however. You can try it free for 34 days. After that it costs $11.99 a month or $84 a year for the annual plan. The cost is the biggest downside to YNAB.

6. PocketSmith

PocketSmith started out as a calendar to plan upcoming income and expenses. Today, it’s a full-fledged budgeting app. You can sync your accounts with PocketSmith. Once synced, you can track your budget and you’re net worth. You can also see your income and spending in a handy calendar view.

Key features of Pocketsmith include:

Manage multiple income streams
Forecast your cashflow, including tools to help you reach FIRE (financial independence, retire early)
Track Airbnb earnings
Create and track savings goals
Integrates with Xero
Multi-currency

7. Fidelity Full View

Fidelity’s Full View is powered by eMoneyAdvisor, a tool used by financial planners. While Fidelity’s Full View doesn’t come with all of eMoneyAdvisor’s features, it’s still a robust tool, free, and available even if you don’t have an account at Fidelity.

Fidelity Full View includes the following features:

Consolidate accounts in one place
Track your net worth over time
Create and manage a budget
View transactions
Integrates with Fidelity’s planning tools

Other Mint Replacement Options

I’m regularly evaluating new financial tools. As I do, I’ll add them to this list to help those looking to leave Mint. Here are some of the options I’m evaluating:

Every Dollar: The Dave Ramsey budgeting solution. While Dave is popular with those paying off debt, this solution is one of the most expensive and it doesn’t have near the features that a tool like Personal Capital offers.
Banktivity: One of the few budgeting apps designed for the Mac, Banktivity is another option. One question to consider though is whether an iOS specific software is necessary today. Everything is online or in an app.
Unifimoney: This app is designed for high earning professionals. It combines money management tools with saving, spending and investing services.

Why Switch from Mint?

Mint continues to offer a free, solid budgeting app. There are, however, several reasons to consider an alternative.

The first is its limited investing tools. While you can track your investments in Mint, the many of the options here offer far better investing tools. Personal Capital, for example, shows a portfolio’s asset allocation, investment fees, and retirement readiness.

Second, Mint uses an advertising revenue model. The result is a user experience plastered with ads.

Mythodology

My first step in evaluating Mint alternatives was to use dozens of budgeting and investment tracking apps. I’ve used each of the tools in our list extensively, with the exception of Pocketsmith and CountAbout (I’m working on those two now). I’ve also undertaken indepth research into these and more than 25 other options.

In evaluating these apps, I focused on the following key criteria:

Cost
Ease of use
Mobile app availability
Ability to consolidate all accounts in one place
Budgeting tools
Investment tracking tools

Mint Alternatives FAQs

What is the best free alternative to Mint?

Personal Capital is the best free Mint replacement. It comes with nearly every feature Mint offers, and many additional tools. It’s particularly well suited for those who want to manage all of their money in one place, including investments.

What is the best option to migrate Mint data to new app?

If you want to migrate Mint data to a new budgeting app, CountAbout is a solid option. It has features enabling users to migrate data from Mint.

What is the best Mint replacement for calendar budgeting?

PocketSmith is a good choice as it offers a calendar view of your budget.

Which Mint alternatives allow you to schedule bill payments?

With both Tiller Money and YNAB, you can plan future bill payments. Tiller offers a Bill Payment Tracker template and YNAB enables you to allocate funds to bills you plan to pay in the future.

Should I switch from Mint.com?

Mint continues to offer a solid budgeting and investment tracking app. Some, however, have complained about issues connecting Mint to banks and other financial institutions. It also uses an advertising revenue model, so users are inundated with ads.

Whatever tool you choose, the key is to pick one that works for you. For me, that’s Personal Capital. One or more of the above Mint alternatives, however, should suit the needs of most looking to better manage their money.

9 Best Investment Tracking Apps in 2022

January 16, 2022 by Rob Berger

The ideal investment tracking app makes managing investments a breeze. Investment apps can track not only the portfolio’s performance, but also its fees, asset allocation and projected future growth. What follows are the best investment tracking apps based on numerous factors, including cost, features and ease of use.

Investment Tracking Apps — Best Investment Tracking Tools

Table Of Contents

Summary of Best Investment Tracking Apps
How to Choose the Best Investment Tracking App
Methodology
FAQs
Other Portfolio Management Apps I’m Tracking

Summary of Best Investment Tracking Apps

Personal Capital

Personal Capital is our Editor’s Choice, and an investment tracking app that I’ve used for many years. It earns our top ranking for several reasons. First, once you link your investment accounts to Personal Capital it automatically downloads all of your transaction, balance and returns data. It can link both retirement and non-retirement accounts.

Second, in addition to performance data, it gives you data on the fees charged by each of your investments, and how those fees will affect your wealth over time. Third, It integrates all of your data into a robust retirement calculator you can use to plan your future retirement.

You can link bank accounts, credit cards, investment accounts and even the value of your home through Zillow. In this regard, Personal Capital enables you to manage all of your finances, not just your investments.

Pros

Free
Automatically downloads all of your financial data
Tracks your asset allocation
Tracks your investment fees
Integrates with a robust retirement tool

Cons

Personal Capital will contact you about their investment advisory services

Try Personal Capital

Stock Rover

For those with more complicates stock portfolios, Stock Rover is an excellent option. There is a learning curve to this tool, but they provide video guides and plenty of help. Stock Rover provides a wealth of data on stocks, ETFs and mutual funds. And it also offers countless ways to evaluate individual investments or your portfolio as a whole.

The app enables you to connect all your investment accounts for automatic updates. Alternatively, you can enter your portfolio manually. It also offers pre-set portfolios you can use for evaluation purposes.

Pros

Robust tools and reporting
Connects to your brokerage and retirement accounts
Dividend income calendar
Countless charts to evaluate any investments

Cons

It requires an annual fee, although a reasonable one
Because of its rich features, there is a learning curve

Google Sheets

For those who don’t want to connect their financial accounts to an app, Google Sheets is ideal. Using the Google finance function, you can pull in data on mutual funds, ETFs and stocks. This can include a fund or company’s name, its price, performance, and its expense ratio.

For those that don’t want to create their own, I’ve created a free investment tracking spreadsheet that you can use.

Pros

Free
Doesn’t require connecting financial accounts to an app
Google Finance functions automatically download some fund and stock data

Cons

Share totals are not automatically updated
Asset allocation is limited
No retirement planning tool
No fee analyzer tool

Tiller

Tiller is without question my all time favorite budgeting app. What many don’t know, however, is that you can also use it to track your investments. At present, you can connect all of your investment accounts and Tiller will download your transactions and account balances.

It also has a retirement add-on that can determine your path to retirement. I recently spoke with the folks at Tiller and understand that they are also working on another add-one that will give you insight into your asset allocation.

Pros

Very easy to use
Integrates not just investment tracking but also budgeting
Uses Google Sheets so it’s ideal for those who love spreadsheets

Cons

Investment analysis tools are currently still limited
After a 30 day free trial it costs $79 a year

Morningstar

Morningstar is another tool that I’ve used for many years. In fact, I’ve created a YouTube video course that walks through how to use the robust tools offered by Morningstar. The tools include a portfolio tracker.

The one downside is that you have to enter your portfolio manually. You also have to update it manually. As a result, it takes a lot of work to keep your portfolio updated. On the plus side, Morningstar offers arguably the most robust amount of tools and analysis available today.

Pros

Excellent investment tools and analysis
Track performance to the penny, including dividend reinvestments
Excellent mutual fund and ETF analysis tools
Free for basic portfolio tracker

Cons

Data must be entered manually
Data must be updated manually
$199 annual fee to get access to all the morning stars data and tools

Quicken Premier

Quicken is arguably the longest surviving budgeting and personal finance software. I was using it more than 20 years ago. Today with Quicken Premier you can track your investments, including your performance and realized and unrealized gains. And it has tools to make preparing your taxes easier. It also pulls in data from Morningstar. On the downside, however, there’s an annual fee for the software of approximately $75.

Pros

Tracks performance of investments
Tracks cost basis
Makes taxes easier

Cons

Quicken is somewhat outdated
Costs approximately $75 a year

I’ve used Quicken Premier to track investments, but today I prefer several Quicken alternatives for both investment tracking and budgeting.

Mint.com

Mint allows you to track all of your investments online. Similar to Personal Capital you connect both investment accounts as well as banking accounts and Mint downloads transactions and balances for you.

It comes with portfolio tracking for investments. It will keep track of your portfolio’s performance, and any investment fees you’re being charged. One big downside to Mint.com is it uses an advertising model. As a result, sometimes it can feel like you’re being bombarded with ads. For this reason, there are several Mint alternatives to consider.

Pros

It’s free
Can manage all of your finances
Automatically downloads transactions and balances

Cons

Advertising based
Limited investment and portfolio analysis tools

Fidelity Full View

The last investment tracking app on our list is Fidelity Full View. Fidelity’s tool is powered by eMoneyAdvisor, a finance app used exclusively by financial planners. I have access and use eMoneyAdvisor through a financial planner I work with (although I manage our own investments). With Fidelity Full View, however, you can get many of eMoneyAdvisor’s tools without going through an advisor.

For example, Full View enables you to track your portfolio’s performance and asset allocation. You can track your net worth and spending as well. It doesn’t, however, offer the same reporting that eMoneyAdvisor offers.

Pros

Free
Tracks asset allocation
Monitors spending
Tracks net worth

Cons

Limited reporting
Reports and graphs could be better

Kubera

Kubera is the newest investment app in the list. I’ve added it for its simplicity and a few features no other app on our list offers. First, understand that Kubera has very few features. You can connect investment accounts, your home’s value (via Zillow) and even the value of internet domains you own.

Its visual presentation is clean and simple. You can organize your investments in buckets. For example, you could separate retirement, taxable, HSA and real estate. It provides a net worth summary with graphs. You can also track insurance policies, store important documents in its virtual “Safe Deposit Box,” and add “beneficiaries” who can receive all the information in your account should you die.

What Kubera doesn’t offer, however, is any analysis of your investment portfolio. There’s no asset allocation or fee analysis, and there is no retirement planner. On top of these limitations, Kubera costs $15 a month.

Pros

Clean, simple interface
Connect investment accounts
Track real estate, domains and insurance policies
Tracks net worth

Cons

$15/month or $150/year
No investment analysis
Graphs and charts limited

How to Choose the Best Investment Tracking App

The best way to track your investments depends on the complexity of your portfolio. For those with just a single account, a portfolio tracking app isn’t necessary. If all of your investments are in a 401k at work, you can simply track and manage your investments through the brokerage that holds your 401k. Likewise, if you have a single IRA account, you can track that investment easily wherever it is being held.

If you’re looking to open an IRA here are the best IRA accounts available today.

If, like me, you have multiple investment accounts, a tracking app is the best way to manage your investments. That’s particularly true if you hold investments at different brokers. This is common when individuals open up IRAs at brokers and have 401k’s elsewhere. It’s also common with spouses who often have retirement accounts at different financial institutions.

For these types of portfolios, an investment tracker that automatically downloads transactions and balances is ideal. Here, you want to look for an investment app that offers tools to help you analyze your portfolio. The most important tools give you insight into your asset allocation, investment fees and retirement readiness.

We rate Personal Capital as the absolute best investment tracking app, because it does all of this for free. The other apps in our list are also good options.

Methodology

The methodology used in selecting the best investment tracking apps was simple–I’ve used each and every one of them, along with dozens of other options not listed. In most cases, I’ve used the software for years.

I based the selection on several factors:

Cost
Automation
Investment analysis tools
Retirement planning tools
Ease of use
Dashboards, charts and reports

FAQs

What is the best investment tracking app?

In my view, the single best investment tracking tool is Personal Capital. It’s free and automated and comes with a wealth of investment analysis tools.

Are investment tracking apps hard to use?

Some are and some are not. With tools like Personal Capital or Quicken, It’s simply a matter of connecting your investment accounts. Once connected, the tools analyze all of the data and present it in a way that’s easy to understand.

Some software that must be downloaded, however, has a much higher learning curve. And for that reason did not make our list of the best options.

How do I set up investment tracking alerts with many of the tools on our list?

You can get notified when any transactions occur in your account. Personal Capital for example, will email you every day, week or month to notify you of any transactions in your linked accounts.

Other Portfolio Management Apps I’m Tracking

The above apps are the best I’ve found, but I am evaluating other stock tools:

Stock Rover: I’ve been using this tool for several weeks and really like it. It can be used for index fund investors, stock traders, and everybody in between. It includes tons of research data, useful historical data, and even asset allocation portfolios you can examine.

EquityStat: Another stock tracker with a clean interface. It’s ideal for tracking the performance of an investment portfolio. Unfortunately, it doesn’t give you any insight into the asset allocation of a portfolio.